Summary dismissal and witchcraft in the workplace

Witchcraft in the workplace
02 Jun 2017

The commissioner in the recent case of National Sugar refining and Allied industries Union obo Mngomezulu v Tongaat Hulette Sugar Ltd [2016] 11 BALR 11 BALR 1172 (NBCSMRI) was faced with determining whether or not placing a black slimy substance on the handle and tyre of a colleague’s car amounted to an act of witchcraft intended to cause harm and, if so, whether or not this was a dismissible offence.

Following a strained relationship between Mr Mngomezulu (a shop steward) and the Human Resources Manager of Operations, Ms Nxele, Mr Mngomezulu placed a black slimy substance on the handle and tire of Ms Nxele’s car. In providing her evidence before the commissioner, Ms Nxele testified that, despite being a Christian, when she discovered the substance she “had an urge in her spirit to pray” because she believed the substance to be “muti”. Muti is a form of traditional medicine used for the purposes of healing or causing harm.

While there was a dispute about the nature of the substance which necessitated the introduction of expert evidence by two Sangomas (traditional healer or diviner), the commissioner ruled that the nature of the substance is inconsequential. What is of consequence is what Ms Nxele perceived it to be and her reaction to it. It was further held that the act of witchcraft does not have to achieve its purpose for it to become an act of misconduct and that the mere use of muti or traditional preparations to intimidate, scare or threaten another person is sufficient. To this end, the commissioner accepted that the conduct of Mr Mngomezulu caused Ms Nxele grief and that the placement of the substance was an attempt to psychologically exploit Ms Nxele and create fear and panic in her for herself, her family and her possessions. Accordingly, the commissioner held that Mr Mngomezulu’s conduct amounts to serious intimidation which cannot be tolerated in the workplace and justified a sanction of summary dismissal. This is because Mr Mngomezulu’s conduct irreparably harmed the trust relationship between himself and a colleague with who he works intimately and, consequently, negatively affected the trust relationship between himself and his employer.

While witchcraft may be viewed with scepticism from a Western perspective, its existence is widely believed by many persons in South Africa and it is practised within South Africa and Africa. In the circumstances, employers must be aware of the religious (and other) practices of their employees, the effect that such practices may have on working relationships within the workplace and how best to manage such practices. Witchcraft may constitute gross misconduct relating to intimidation and even insolence in cases where the “victim” does not necessarily believe in witchcraft and employees could be disciplined when participating in such practices at the workplace. Conversely, false accusations of witchcraft in the workplace ought to attract disciplinary action and can be likened to, for example, false accusations of racism.

Sandro Milo
Sandro Milo

Sandro Milo is a partner at Eversheds Sutherland's litigation group. He specialises in all aspects of litigation and arbitration, employment, and black economic empowerment law. Sandro is also an expert in the education sector and regularly advises tertiary institutions on the particular challenges facing this sector. He provides seminars and training to tertiary institutions, the Department of Education and his other clients on a wide variety of subjects.

Send a legal query to Sandro Milo
Nadia Froneman
Nadia Froneman

Nadia Froneman is an associate at Eversheds Sutherland's employment law department. She specialises in all aspects of employment law. Nadia graduated with BSocSci (law and organisational psychology) from Rhodes University in 2012 and in 2014 she obtained her LLB Degree cum lade. She frequently represents her clients in disciplinary and incapacity enquiries and provides advice and opinions on all aspects of employment law. Nadia has received a lot of her training in the education sector and regularly assists in advising tertiary institutions on the particular challenges facing this sector.

Send a legal query to Nadia Froneman
Share


Other Labour Law articles by


Other Labour Law articles on GoLegal

Stay connected to the law industry
Subscribe to our newsletter to receive legal news, announcements, industry events, jobs, and more.
Stay Updated